By-The-Bay Motel Lodging Phone (920) 868-3456 Physical Address4123 Hwy 42Fish Creek, WI 54212 Mailing AddressHwy 42Fish Creek, WI 54212 http://www.bythebaymotel.com/ Get Driving Directions Lodging Information TypeLodgingPrice$90 - $220AmenitiesAir Conditioning