Navigation

Thanksgiving Dining Options

Some of us love the tradition of cooking a big family meal together for Thanksgiving. Others, not so much. And still others simply don’t have family around for the holiday. For you, we did the digging to find restaurants and bakeries that are offering Thanksgiving dining or preparations. The following is a list of the offerings we found as of Wednesday, Nov. 16. 

DINE IN 

The Lodge at Leathem Smith

1640 Memorial Dr. in Sturgeon Bay

The Lodge will offer a traditional Thanksgiving dinner, 11 am – 3 pm. Reservations are recommended. Call 920.743.5555.

Stone Harbor Pub

107 N. 1st Ave. in Sturgeon Bay

Traditional Thanksgiving dinner, 11 am – 3 pm. Reservations are recommended. Call 920.746.0700.

Carrington Pub

7643 Hillside Road in Egg Harbor

Thanksgiving dinner, 11 am – 4 pm. Reservations are required. Call 920.868.3205.

The Fireside Restaurant

7755 Hwy 42 in Egg Harbor

Thanksgiving classics served buffet style, 10 am – 2 pm. Reservations are recommended. Call 920.868.4800.

The English Inn

3713 Hwy 42 in Fish Creek

Plated Thanksgiving meal served 12-7 pm. Reservations are recommended at theenglishinn.com/reservation or by calling 920.868.3076.

Alexander’s

3667 Hwy 42 in Fish Creek

Thanksgiving dinner, 11 am – 4 pm. Reservations are required. Call 920.868.3532.

TO-GO AND DINE IN

Wanda Jean’s Family Restaurant

846 Egg Harbor Road in Sturgeon Bay

Dine-in buffet on Thanksgiving Day, 10 am – 1 pm. Order to-go boxes by Nov. 20 for pickup on Wednesday, Nov. 23, before 5 pm. Call 920.743.0105.

TO-GO ONLY

Scaturo’s Baking Company & Cafe

19 Green Bay Road in Sturgeon Bay

Thanksgiving to-go boxes, plus pies and dinner rolls. Order by Nov. 21 at scaturos.com or by calling 920.746.8727.

Blue Bear

12029 Hwy 42 in Ellison Bay

A Thanksgiving meal for the whole family (serves 8-12) prepared for pickup on Wednesday, Nov. 23. Gluten-free and vegan options are available. Call 920.854.3284 or email [email protected].

Main Street Market

7770 Hwy 42 in Egg Harbor

The deli offers à la carte Thanksgiving dinner options for pickup on Wednesday, Nov. 23, 4-7 pm; and Nov. 24, 8-12 am. Orders must be placed by Nov. 21. Call 920.868.2121.

Savor BBQ

The pickup location will be announced on social media.

Savor is offering a barbecue sampler platter for pickup on Thanksgiving Day. The offering includes Texas-style brisket, pulled pork, ribs, chicken, sides, fixings and rolls. Call or text 920.365.2748, or message Savor on Facebook.

McEvoy’s Culinaria and Paella Catering

2602 S. Bay Shore Dr. in Sister Bay

Traditional Thanksgiving dinner with per-person portions available for pickup on Wednesday, Nov. 23. Call 920.854.8029 by 4 pm on Nov. 19.

Related Organizations